Creativity: The halo, the sea, the 50 cal bullet scrapping the floor - brilliant. The main feel of the montage was still fairly generic though.

Content: The amount of good clips was insane. Great multikills with awesome sniping. The only issues I have with the gameplay is the sheer repetitiveness of sniper clips on host. I know its not something the player can control but seeing every clip on host makes the gameplay less impressive for me.

Editing: The intro was great, especiallt the halo over earth - awesome
It is clear that the editor has a huge amount of editing knowledge however the problem with halo montages today is that editors concentrate too much on cool effects and forget about the flow. The flow was the reason I enjoyed the old montages so much and can watch them time and time again, this unfortunately didnt have enough of that quality.

Music: First 2 songs were great I thought, 3rd song had screaming which is an instant no no for me, even if the rest of the song is awesome.

Quality: Perfect HD with nice contrast, colour correction etc.